Positive culture and great PTO, but disorganized management - Claims Adjuster AmTrust Employee Review

2.0
8 May 2026
Recommend
CEO approval
Business outlook

Pros

+office culture, fun colleagues +amazing PTO plan, 18 days starting + Jewish and Federal Holidays. Usually around 30+ days a YEAR!! +Structured growth plan for the first year +Straightforward job duties, you know what to do, when to do it, and its easy to plan your day. Really nice that they have a ramp up period as well. +Our BIG boss at the office is so nice. I've never met someone so invested in trying to make sure everyone succeeds. He is bubbly, kind, and acts just like a normal person. He doesn't use his position in a way to inflate his ego at all, which has been my experience prior in corporate. +2 week trip to SLC to train, where I got to make a lot of genuine connections with colleagues in different offices which will set me up to be able to transition to new positions in different places in the future.

Cons

- Working out of a coworking space. Deadline keeps getting pushed back and its beginning to be frustrating. It's so cramped, and no space to hide from awkward interactions with those you aren't very fond of. -As a small office, keeping a positive culture is important. One of my managers is INCREDIBLY disorganized, unprofessional, not confident, and condescending, This recently caused the office to rearrange teams under different managers due to conflict on our team. It's hard to know who your actual manager is or who is temporarily your supervisor. -Nobody really knows what's going on in entirety. Everyone is less than 3 months on the job at AmTrust because we are a new office. This causes disorganization. -Expected to front the cost of all meals and transportation in SLC, with unclear deadlines around when that would be expensed back. Was almost 1k while I was there. Been nearly a month and still haven't received. I'm not comfortable providing an interest free loan to a multi-million dollar company. -Our managers are unsure or unclear on what the associate program raise is supposed to be. On our interviews, we were told 5-10%. But our VP and manager said it is a 15% raise in our first week. Imagine how disappointed we will all be when we find out we all are only getting 5% when pay review time comes. We are already paid a lot less than the industry average as our starting wage and if I don't receive closer to 10% I would consider different avenues. - teams chat monitoring. For a job that only gives you 1 day a week hybrid, it shouldn't be apart of the culture to watch if someone's light on teams is green, or orange. A big part of working from home is having flexibility. Our managers don't really seem that busy if they're able to monitor who is active on teams to the extent, they just send messages to check if you're by your computer. Frustrating. I truly believe I would be more productive if we had 2 days a week to work hybrid. This is an industry standard and being forced to come to an office that is extremely cramped to do work 4 days a week is not beneficial or helpful. This needs to change. Many employees are leaving and already expressing on here that the RTO mandate makes no sense.

avatar
AmTrust Response
1mo
Thank you for sharing your feedback. We’re sorry to hear about your experience. It’s important that our employees feel supported, and we encourage you to reach out to the AmTrust Employee Center at AmTrustEmployeeCenter@amtrustgroup.com or our anonymous hotline, 844-331-2374, so we can better understand your concerns.

Explore other reviews about AmTrust

5.0
12 Jun 2026
Recommend
CEO approval
Business outlook

Pros

Flexible work hours. Great co-workers. My co-workers are friendly, easy to talk to and are willing to help you if they are able to.

Cons

Systems can give you issues at times and make it difficult to get work done.

2.0
8 May 2026
Recommend
CEO approval
Business outlook

Pros

Co-workers are amazing. Managers are helpful.

Cons

Rolling out an incomplete new operating system was a horrible idea. Creates additional work for adjusters. The processes being implemented are hindering the ability to effectively close claims. Adjusters are being told to do more with less every day. Claim counts average 180 to 200 for the last 6 months with no relief in sight. Hybrid work was promised at 2 home and 3 in office. That was recently revoked and it is now mandatory 4 days in office. With gas prices what they are, that really hurts. Corporate management seems to be focused more on obtaining #1 status and bringing in the big bucks than finding a way to relieve the stress on their employees. Mental health is non existent and if you aren't putting in 50+ hours a week there is no way to stay on top of your work load. Even then you will feel like you are barely treading water. New NICE phone system is for call centers-not claim adjusters. Not a lot of advancement opportunities unless you are someone's pet. Benefits are mediocre at best.

4
avatar
AmTrust Response
1mo
We appreciate you taking the time to leave a review. Your feedback is important to us, and we’d welcome the opportunity to learn more. Please contact the AmTrust Employee Center at AmTrustEmployeeCenter@amtrustgroup.com or 844-331-2374.
See reviews by: Helpful|Rating|Date|All