You're Just A Number - Supervisor GEICO Employee Review

2.0
8 Nov 2014
Recommend
CEO approval
Business outlook

Pros

-Great peers and I like the majority of people I supervise -Decent benefits -Very stable and well known company -No lay offs unless you cannot perform -Career development and paths for advancement if you put in the work -Promote from within culture -Great support for newly hired employees -Good pay if you don't have a college education

Cons

-No stable scheduling. As an insurance agent you won't get M-F for at least 5 years unless you're a top performer, you'll get anything you want. As a supervisor, expect having split days off until you're there for 10 years. -Extremely micromanaged, my director/manager yell and me to yell at my associates for using time to go to the restroom/taking a few minutes extra on a break or lunch. -Goals are constantly and dramatically raised with little or no time to prepare my team or associates. -Once you're a supervisor, really no place to go since manager is selling your soul to the company. -Underpaid for the amount of work done. As a supervisor you run a team of at least 10 associates and do as much work as people who are managers in other companies. The worst part is maintaining associates HR issues with leave and chasing down your associates to come to work today. -Lack of appreciation for associates and supervisors. Managers and Directors create a work environment where success and accomplishments are expected and not celebrated. Company culture that constantly focuses on what you're doing wrong and not doing enough. Complete lack of positive reinforcement and even when you are doing well, it's not enough. -An illusion of a "meritocracy" where people are promoted based on qualifications. Directors know who they want as supervisors and managers and only hold interviews to make the selection process seem like a competition. -The company is extremely cheap considering they made $20 billion in 2013. When we get free coffee in the department, it is celebrated like Christmas. Good luck trying to get some pens, paper, or a decent keyboard for your computer. You'll have to buy that on your own.

Explore other reviews about GEICO

5.0
10 Jun 2026
Recommend
CEO approval
Business outlook

Pros

helpful team members and leadership beautiful facility with lunch room and gym very clean and organized systems

Cons

hours I was originally offered as a new rep were not the best

5.0
3 Jun 2026
Recommend
CEO approval
Business outlook

Pros

GEICO stands out for its world-class training and onboarding, which gives employees a strong foundation from day one. The training programs are structured, practical, and continuously improved based on feedback, helping new hires ramp quickly and confidently. The company also offers exceptional growth and development opportunities. There are clear paths for advancement across all operational areas (Claims, Service, Sales, etc.), supported by coaching, mentorship, and leadership development programs. Employees have access to tuition assistance, certifications, and professional development resources, making it easier to build a long-term career. GEICO provides strong stability as an established industry leader, with competitive compensation and benefits. The performance-driven culture rewards results and creates opportunities for high performers to advance quickly. Another highlight is the focus on internal mobility and skill-building. Associates are encouraged to expand their capabilities, take on new challenges, and grow into leadership roles through hands-on experience and real-time coaching.

Cons

The environment is performance-driven and fast-paced, which can feel demanding at times, especially during periods of high volume or organizational change. Expectations are high, and success requires strong time management and adaptability. Hybrid/in-office expectations may vary by role and business need, which can be an adjustment depending on personal preferences.

See reviews by: Helpful|Rating|Date|All