Avoid this brand if you’re a motivated/experienced manager. - Associate Store Manager J. Crew Employee Review

1.0
13 Jun 2021
Recommend
CEO approval
Business outlook

Pros

- Generous PTO. - Good employee discounts/incentives.

Cons

- Literally zero emphasis on learning and development for any new hire at any level. - Hands down the worst brand I’ve been with in terms of overall communication whether it be between the store and employees and managers or senior retail team to to store director or HR. Hardly anyone is ever on the same page. - Inconsistency amongst all departments when it comes to stock and deliveries. Every shipment that comes has at least one madewell or J. Crew Factory item that then needs to be shipped back. Also, every week there is at least one customer who comes in to return an item(s) that they didn’t even order. That item then needs to be adjusted by inventory control and then sent out again. The frequency of these stock issues is not even close to what I’ve seen with previous brands. - Uses “complaints” as a performance metric. This brand will never have your back. They are so scared of losing customers that it’s become uncomfortable anytime there’s an issue when it comes to policy that we literally had to just give them what they want because we “can’t have any complaints.” - Literally no LP training or basic LP practices. - Experienced and long tenured Store Directors apparently have an unwritten allowance to take off more weekends than usual and never have to close. Must be nice! - Most importantly, there is a complete lack of leadership not only in the location that I worked at but throughout the company it seems. There is no plan. No thoughts about developing talent. The minute you come to leadership with any issues or wanting change they don’t really listen or take any action. They just immediately assume that you’re not happy and you’ll just leave. Just an absolutely poor culture and an absolute shock that this brand has a 3.9 rating.

Explore other reviews about J. Crew

5.0
31 May 2026
Recommend
CEO approval
Business outlook

Pros

Great team and flexible hours

Cons

Nothing to complain about here

4.0
29 May 2026
Recommend
CEO approval
Business outlook

Pros

Really nice working culture, everyone is collaborative and working together. Very low employees turnover

Cons

Pay could be better. Leadership not aligned, lots of changes and stress falling on production to make it haplen

See reviews by: Helpful|Rating|Date|All